There's so much to see and ponder over in Shyam Benegal's epic "Bose
- The Forgotten Hero". One cannot really take it all in during one viewing.
To do full justice to Benegal's achievement one needs to go back to
the work's nuances in leisure.
I've done that. I've waited a week before writing my review.
Bio-pics are tricky things. They work only when the central character
holds up the drama.
To play Subhas Chandra Bose, one of the most turbulent and adventurous
national leaders India has ever produced, couldn't have been easy. Sachin
Khedeker simply slips into Bose's personality. The actor doesn't assume
the legendary nationalist's personality by trying to look like Bose
(though admittedly there's more than a passing resemblance).
Khedeker instead tries to get into the mind and heart of this freedom
fighter who wandered from country to country to glean support for India's
freedom from British rule.
If there was no self-congratulation in Bose's indomitable fight for
self-governance, there's no hamming in Khedeker's portrayal of the enigmatic
hero.
We can stretch the analogy further to include director Benegal in
the web of understatement that characterizes this true-life drama on
the dynamics of political freedom.
The prolific director has lost none of his penchant for creating the
drama of humanism through images that seem at first, ordinary, but are
actually emblems of an existential dilemma.
Wisely, Benegal's astute writers Shama Zaidi and Atul Tiwari focus
on the dialectics of the human drama rather than getting submerged in
the politics of the turbulent period when India sought to find its liberty
from foreign rule.
One of the myths regarding Bose, which the film effectually squashes,
is that Bose was at loggerheads with Mahatma Gandhi. During one of his
many heartwarming conversations with his lieutenants, Bose, getting
sentimental, says no one will ever know his true regard for Gandhi.
Ideological conflicts spring out of this socio-political epic to qualify
and define the man and the politician. There's no confusion or overlapping
between the two roles in Benegal's vast range of vision. Thanks to his
extraordinary team of actors and technicians, the filmmaker ably re-constructs
Bose's life and ideology as being two halves of one remarkable personality.
The battle sequences shot on location are gratifyingly authentic. But
it's the humane moments which motivate Benegal's script to humanise
Bose and make him appear more of a wandering ideologue than as the fiery
rebellious misfit that Indian history has chosen to judge him. The controversial
portions where Benegal's Bose is shown to marry a German woman and produce
a baby girl are done with the soft but firm hands of a visionary who
won't let history obstruct his vision of the protagonist's personality.
All through Bose's struggle for India's freedom from foreign shores
we see him as a pragmatic yet sensitive patriot. A great deal of the
film's compelling conviction comes from the actors.
The film springs a number of marvelous performances. While Khedeker
runs across the narrative in a zigzag of inter-personal politics, the
other members of the cast come and go creating a compendium of ambrosial
cameos.
Divya Dutta (watch her where she pretends to feed kheer - rice pudding
- to the missing Bose in their Kolkata home), Ila Arun (watch her in
the farewell sequence in Kabul where she gifts Bose with three gold
coins to free her country) and Rajit Kapur (constantly shadowing Bose)
are outstanding in their own space.Remarkably enough Benegal casts truly
competent actors in the Anglo-Saxon roles. Everyone, from Hitler (Udo
Schenk) to Bose's wife Emile (Anna Prustel) belong in this outstanding
tribute to a 'forgotten' hero.
My final
verdict on the film: Bose according to Benegal is a man and a state
of mind which provoke flaming thoughts of nationalism and patriotic
chauvinism. There isn't a single desultory moment in the lengthy narration.
On the contrary some portions seem to have been over-edited by Aseem
Sinha to suit the needs of the impatient theatre exhibitors.
In the pursuit of a mass audience Benegal never vanquishes the essence
and humanistic core of his protagonist. All through the progression
of the plot, as Bose travels from Kabul to Berlin to Tokyo and Burma
in search of national identity for India, we see him as more of a missionary
than a messiah.
Rahen Kothari's cinematography and Samir Chanda's art work add a sheen
of no-nonsense nostalgia to the predominantly autobiographical tale.
Dialogue writer Atul Tiwari has made sure that the burning patriotism
of the political drama doesn't get mired in polemics.
Sure, Sachin Khedeker gets his share of rabblerousing rhetorics. But
most of the time he's on his own carving a personality out of the clay
of history without becoming a slave to the role model. It's a truly
accomplished performance and one without which Bose the man, politician
and the film, couldn't have been possible.
Like all bio-pics "Bose.." poses a perceptional problem for the lay
audience. It offers scores and scores of characters within a historical
perspective that is unintelligible to the dude who thinks Tusshar Kapoor
and the cat in "Kya Kool Hain Hum" are engaging.
Among the films of today and in the autobiographical genre "Bose.."
stands tall. Its underscored but accentuated view of a stunning slice
of history is unadulterated by humbug. And yet Benegal has made sure
we watch a life well worth living without getting bored.
To me, that's the biggest achievement of this neglected gem.