It might not seem fair to compare the two cousins.
But since it is confirmed that Kajol is playing a blind girl in "Fanaa",
Rani Mukerji's performance in "Black" immediately springs
to mind.
Rani has bagged all the popular awards for her stupendous
performance in the role of a blind-deaf-mute girl in Sanjay Leela Bhansali's
"Black"?
Her success with the role has certainly set a high standard for Bollywood
beauties, including Kajol who is making a comeback after four years
with "Fanaa" produced by Yash Raj Films and directed by Kunal
Kohli.
But from the perspective of treatment, "Black" and "Fanaa"
seem worlds apart. The only similarity is both films talk about the
struggle of physically impaired heroines and their unbridled emotions.
"Fanaa", which is said to have shades of "Noorie"
and "Dil Se", is the love story of a terrorist and a Kashmiri
girl, who is deprived of the pleasures of life. The entry of a young
man changes her life and she goes through several emotional ups and
downs in the film.
Unlike "Black" where Rani kept oscillating between black
and white, Kohli's "Fanaa" is more colourful and vibrant and
exudes all the hues of life.
Kajol is an exceptional performer and has breathed freshness and vitality
into every role she has played - from "Kuch Kuch Hota Hai",
"Dushman", and "Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge" to
"Yeh Dillagi" and "Baazigar" among many others.
Happily married to Ajay Devgan, Kajol has for some time been focussing
on her young daughter.
Rani, in her absence, has established herself as a bankable actor
and her performances in "Saathiya", "Chalte Chalte",
"Yuva", "Hum Tum", "Veer-Zaara", "Bunty
Aur Babli", "Paheli" and "Black" speak volumes
for her. She is said to be the reigning queen of Hindi films.
Another platform for comparison is the pairing with Aamir. Kajol will
star opposite the actor for the first time in "Fanaa".
On the other hand Rani has earlier acted opposite Aamir who is known
to be a perfectionist and is sometimes accused of eclipsing his co-stars.
Audience liked their onscreen chemistry in "Ghulam" and "Mangal
Pandey - The Rising". Rani has never seemed overawed by Aamir's
presence.
"Fanaa" promos seem to suggest that the Aamir-Kajol paring
too is likely to fire up the box office.
In the looks department, Kajol is still a stunner - the flab has disappeared,
she is trimmer and prettier than ever before. And that's not surprising,
given that Yash Raj Films is known to give special attention to the
appearances of its cast.
The film has several firsts - Kajol has never played a physically
impaired girl before; neither has Aamir played a terrorist.
Also, for the first time Kajol has rendered a song for the film with
Aamir.
This is also yesteryear lover boy Rishi Kapoor's first stint with
Aamir.
"Fanaa", which is scheduled for a May release, certainly
reflects the Yash Chopra stamp - a mature romance blooming in exotic
locales laced with exhilarating music.